Broken steel bolt flush with a metal workpiece, with spiral screw extractor, centre punch and drill bit nearby

How to Remove a Broken Screw or Bolt with a Screw Extractor

OnlyScrews Hardware Guide · Article 19

A snapped bolt or stripped screw can stop an entire repair. A screw extractor helps remove the damaged fastener by gripping a drilled hole in its remaining body, allowing you to turn it out without unnecessarily damaging the surrounding threads. Learn how to choose the right extractor and use it safely.

Broken steel bolt flush with a metal workpiece, with a spiral screw extractor, centre punch and drill bit nearby
A broken fastener, a drill bit and a screw extractor: success starts with the right size and accurate alignment.

1. What is a screw extractor and how does it work?

A screw extractor is a hardened cutting or gripping tool used to remove damaged screws, bolts and studs. The common tapered spiral extractor has reverse-spiral flutes that grip the inside of a pilot hole. As the extractor is turned anticlockwise, it engages the broken fastener and can transmit torque to unscrew a conventional right-hand threaded screw.

The tapered design can also exert outward pressure on the fastener as it engages. This means that forcing the extractor deeper or applying excessive torque can make a seized fastener even harder to remove. The aim is controlled grip, not maximum force.

Quick answer: Choose an extractor for the original fastener diameter, drill the pilot hole specified for that extractor, engage the tool, and turn it slowly by hand in the correct loosening direction. Stop if it will not move.

2. When should you use a screw extractor?

Fastener condition Best approach to consider
Rounded or stripped drive, head intact First try a correctly fitting driver or a suitable damaged-head removal tool. A drill-and-extract method may be appropriate if the easier method fails.
Broken below or flush with the surface Centred pilot drilling and a compatible spiral extractor, if access and material allow.
Broken with enough shank protruding Try a suitable gripping tool first, without crushing the surrounding component.
Severely seized, corroded or galled fastener Assess the cause and use an appropriate loosening method; if resistance remains high, seek professional removal.
Broken hardened tap or extractor Use a dedicated broken-tool removal process; a conventional screw extractor is usually inappropriate.

3. Screw extractor size chart (3–22 mm)

The current OnlyScrews 6-piece screw extractor set is listed in high-grade steel with a 45° cutting angle and a plastic storage case. Its six extractor sizes are intended for the following original screw diameter ranges:

Six spiral screw extractors arranged from smallest to largest on a dark workbench
Illustrative size progression. Select the numbered extractor using its actual markings and the supplier's size chart.
Extractor number Listed fastener diameter range
#1 3–6 mm
#2 6–8 mm
#3 8–11 mm
#4 11–14 mm
#5 14–18 mm
#6 18–22 mm

Important: These are original fastener diameter ranges, not pilot drill diameters. At overlapping range boundaries, follow the extractor's markings and instructions. The current listing does not specify exact pilot drill sizes or drilling depths for each numbered extractor; obtain those dimensions before drilling. Do not substitute a tapping drill chart.

4. Tools to prepare before extraction

  • A correctly sized spiral screw extractor.
  • A suitable centre punch and drill bit rated for the fastener material.
  • A drill with controllable speed and a means of keeping it aligned.
  • A compatible hand wrench or tap wrench that securely grips the extractor's drive end.
  • A measuring tool, appropriate cutting fluid, penetrating oil where suitable, eye protection, a vice or other secure fixture, and a brush for chips.

Confirm that the wrench fits the actual extractor shank, rather than choosing it solely by the fastener size. Remove sensitive nearby parts and check the available drilling depth, especially around blind holes and thin-walled components.

5. How to remove a broken screw or bolt with a screw extractor

Step 1 — Inspect and secure the workpiece

Determine whether the original screw has a right-hand or left-hand thread. Isolate machinery from power, support the part securely and wear eye protection. Assess the amount of remaining metal, access and whether the fastener is severely seized.

Step 2 — Prepare the damaged fastener

Remove dirt and loose debris. Use an appropriate penetrating oil if the threads are accessible and the material and application permit it. Give it time to penetrate. If the bolt top is irregular or slanted, consider a guided drilling setup; do not begin freehand drilling if the drill is likely to wander.

Step 3 — Mark the centre

Locate the centre of the remaining fastener and mark it with a suitable centre punch, where practical. The goal is to keep the pilot hole inside the broken fastener, not cut into the surrounding female threads.

Step 4 — Drill the specified pilot hole

A drill bit aligned with the centre of a broken bolt embedded in a secured metal block
Drill centrally and keep the drill axis aligned with the fastener. Use the correct pilot-hole dimensions for the chosen extractor.

Choose the bit diameter and depth specified by the extractor manufacturer. Use appropriate drilling speed, feed and cutting fluid for the fastener material. A compatible left-hand drill may sometimes loosen a conventional right-hand-threaded bolt during drilling; this is not guaranteed.

Step 5 — Engage the extractor

Clear loose chips and insert the matching extractor into the pilot hole. Seat it only as directed by the tool manufacturer. Avoid aggressive hammering or driving the taper deeper than necessary.

Step 6 — Turn slowly by hand

Hands turning a T-handle wrench attached to a spiral extractor in a clamped workpiece
Use balanced hand pressure and keep the extractor aligned. Never use an impact wrench for this operation.

Grip the extractor's specified drive end with a compatible wrench. For a standard right-hand-threaded screw and reverse-spiral extractor, turn anticlockwise slowly with balanced pressure. Do not apply sideways bending or jerk the wrench. Stop immediately if the extractor twists, slips or resists.

Step 7 — Remove the broken screw

Once the fastener starts moving, continue gently in the loosening direction until it comes out. Remove the extractor from the recovered fastener using the manufacturer's recommended method.

Step 8 — Inspect and replace

Clear chips, inspect the female threads and verify the replacement fastener's diameter, pitch, length and material grade. If the threads have been damaged, assess a suitable thread repair such as an approved insert before reassembly. Do not reinstall a damaged fastener.

Safety: A hardened extractor can fracture when overloaded. Stop if the fastener will not loosen with controlled hand pressure. Do not use a powered impact driver, extension bar or high torque to force a conventional spiral extractor. Keep hands away from rotating drill bits and never drill into a loaded or energised assembly.

6. What if the screw extractor is not working?

Problem What to check
Drill wanders off centre Stop drilling; re-evaluate the centre mark, fractured surface and guided setup. Avoid damaging the parent threads.
Extractor slips inside the hole Check the pilot diameter, extractor size, seating depth and whether the gripping edges are worn.
Extractor grips but the bolt does not turn Stop applying torque. Assess corrosion, threadlocker, galling, bottoming or thread deformation. A tapered extractor can wedge the bolt further.
Extractor breaks in the hole Stop. Hardened fragments can be very difficult to drill out; a specialist machining method such as EDM may be needed where appropriate.

Removing a broken stainless steel bolt

Stainless steel can be prone to work hardening during drilling and galling in threaded joints. Use suitable sharp tooling, maintain an appropriate cutting feed and avoid prolonged rubbing. Do not assume that every standard extractor can remove a high-strength or badly seized stainless fastener. If a safety-critical or expensive component is involved, use a qualified repair service.

7. Common mistakes to avoid

  • Treating the original screw diameter as the pilot-hole drill diameter.
  • Drilling at an angle or through the bottom of a blind hole.
  • Using the wrong removal direction for the fastener thread.
  • Driving a tapered extractor too far into a seized bolt.
  • Applying excessive torque or sideways force to a hardened extractor.
  • Reusing damaged screws or neglecting to inspect the threaded hole.

Frequently asked questions

Can a screw extractor remove a bolt broken flush with the surface?

Yes, provided there is enough accessible material to make the correct centred pilot hole and the remaining bolt can be loosened.

Which extractor should I use for an M6 screw?

The OnlyScrews chart places 6 mm at the boundary of #1 and #2. Confirm the actual extractor's instructions and specified pilot hole before choosing; do not drill a 6 mm hole simply because the screw is M6.

Should I turn a screw extractor clockwise or anticlockwise?

A conventional reverse-spiral extractor is turned anticlockwise to remove an ordinary right-hand-threaded fastener. Left-hand threads require a suitable different extraction approach.

Can I use a drill to turn a manual spiral extractor?

Use a suitable manual wrench for the conventional extractor described here. Powered or impact operation can overload the tool; only use power tools with an extractor explicitly intended for that method.

Can an extractor remove a broken tap?

Not reliably. Hardened taps can be difficult to drill and need a dedicated tap extractor or specialist removal method.

Will a screw extractor always save the original threads?

No. Careful alignment and size selection lower the risk of damage, but seizure, misalignment and previous damage may require professional thread repair.

Find the right screw extractor

Explore the six-piece OnlyScrews extractor set for damaged fasteners in the listed 3–22 mm range. Check current availability and confirm the required pilot drill dimensions before starting.

View screw extractor set

Related reading: How to measure screw diameter, Metric thread pitch guide and How to install a Helicoil insert.

Technical reference: ICS Cutting Tools — screw extractor usage; ICS Cutting Tools — extractor types; OnlyScrews — current size chart and product specification. The manufacturer references provide general technical guidance, not certified specifications for the OnlyScrews SKU. Photographs are illustrative and are not exact product photographs or engineering drawings.

Back to blog